Should You Buy a Leasehold Property with a Short Lease for Rental Income?

Buying a leasehold property with a short lease can appear to be an attractive investment opportunity, especially if it’s priced lower than similar properties and offers strong rental potential. However, this type of purchase comes with both opportunities and significant risks that require careful consideration.

The Opportunity

In the scenario you described, a leasehold property is being sold for £70,000 with a service charge of £120 per year, and it has the potential to generate rental income of £900 per month. On the surface, the numbers may seem appealing—especially if you’re buying the property with cash and plan to extend the lease later on.

Here’s why investors might consider this option:

  1. Low Purchase Price
    Properties with short leases are typically priced lower than similar properties with longer leases. This provides an opportunity to buy at a discount, generate rental income, and later increase the property’s value by extending the lease.
  2. Strong Rental Income
    A monthly rent of £900 on a £70,000 purchase equates to an impressive gross rental yield of approximately 15.4%. For comparison, most rental properties achieve yields in the 4-8% range.
  3. Potential to Add Value
    Extending the lease after purchase can significantly increase the property’s value. For example, a lease extended to 99 or 125 years could potentially raise the market value of the property well above your initial purchase price.

The Risks

Despite the potential upside, buying a leasehold property with only 56 years remaining on the lease is not without risks:

  1. Cost of Lease Extension
    Extending a lease with fewer than 80 years remaining can be expensive. Under UK law, lease extension costs typically include:
    • Marriage Value: When the lease drops below 80 years, the freeholder is entitled to a share of the increase in property value resulting from the extension. This can make extending short leases significantly more expensive.
    • Premium for Extension: The cost of extending a lease depends on the property’s value, the ground rent, and the length of the remaining lease. Lease extensions on short leases can easily run into tens of thousands of pounds.
    • Professional Fees: You’ll need to pay for a solicitor and a surveyor to negotiate the extension and calculate its cost.
    Tip: Before proceeding, it’s essential to obtain a professional valuation to estimate the cost of extending the lease.
  2. Lender Restrictions
    If you later plan to sell the property, short leases can limit your pool of buyers. Most mortgage lenders refuse to lend on properties with less than 70 years remaining on the lease, which could make it difficult for future buyers to secure financing.
  3. Depreciating Asset
    A leasehold property with a short lease is a depreciating asset. If the lease isn’t extended, the property’s value will decrease over time, and selling it could become challenging.
  4. Rental Market Risks
    While £900 per month seems like an attractive rental income, there are risks to consider:
    • Void Periods: How confident are you that the property will consistently be rented out? If the area has high vacancy rates, your returns could be lower than expected.
    • Maintenance and Service Charges: While the service charge is currently £120 per year, this could increase in the future, reducing your net returns.
  5. Freeholder Obligations
    As a leaseholder, you are obligated to comply with the freeholder’s terms. Check the lease for any restrictions on subletting, as some freeholders prohibit letting the property out.

Key Considerations Before Buying

  1. Get a Professional Lease Extension Estimate
    Speak to a solicitor or lease extension specialist to get an accurate estimate of the cost to extend the lease. This will help you assess whether the investment is financially viable.
  2. Review the Lease Terms
    Carefully review the lease agreement for any clauses that might impact your plans. Specifically, look for clauses related to subletting, ground rent increases, or additional fees that may be charged by the freeholder.
  3. Evaluate the Area’s Rental Market
    Ensure the property’s rental potential aligns with your expectations. Research comparable properties in the area to confirm that £900 per month is a realistic rent and that there’s strong demand for rentals.
  4. Plan for the Lease Extension
    Decide when and how you’ll extend the lease. Keep in mind that waiting longer will increase the cost, as the lease will continue to shorten.
  5. Consider Alternative Investments
    While this property offers a high yield, it also carries risks. Compare this opportunity with other buy-to-let properties or investment options to ensure it’s the right fit for your financial goals.

Alternatives to Buying Short-Lease Properties

If the risks associated with short-lease properties seem too high, consider these alternatives:

  1. Freehold Properties
    Buying a freehold property eliminates concerns about lease extensions, ground rent, and freeholder restrictions.
  2. Long-Leasehold Properties
    Look for leasehold properties with at least 80–100 years remaining. These are easier to finance and sell and don’t incur “marriage value” when extending the lease.
  3. Commercial Properties
    Commercial buy-to-let investments often yield higher returns and come with longer lease agreements, reducing tenant turnover.

Final Thoughts

Buying a leasehold property with a short lease can be a lucrative investment if managed carefully. The key is to fully understand the costs and risks associated with the lease extension and rental process. Before proceeding, gather all the facts, consult professionals, and ensure the numbers align with your long-term investment strategy.

For landlords who are experienced or willing to navigate the complexities, this type of investment can offer high yields and significant capital growth after extending the lease. However, if you’re new to property investment or risk-averse, it might be worth considering alternatives with fewer complications.

Join The Discussion

Compare listings

Compare